Electric guitars

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII

The PRS McCarty 594 combines a mahogany-and-maple build with two McCarty III humbuckers and coil-splitting controls. Check the scale-length and color details with the seller before purchasing, since the supplied specifications conflict.

★★★★★ 4.5/5 · 2 buyer reviews · 5 min read · updated 2026-10-07 · Tested by Cal Whitaker

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII review

The PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII is a U.S.-made electric guitar built around a mahogany body, a flamed maple top, and two PRS McCarty III humbuckers. Its specification combines a traditional-style stoptail bridge and vintage-style tuners with a coil-split function operated by push-pull tone controls. The supplied information lists a price of 4,999, but does not identify a currency, so that figure should be checked against the seller's listing.

There are no customer reviews available for this model in the supplied information. This assessment is therefore limited to the listed construction, hardware, and electronics. It cannot establish how a particular example sounds, feels, or performs in use.

Body, top, and finish

The body is mahogany, while the top is described more specifically as flamed maple. The finish is listed as Black Top, and the general color field gives Charcoal. Those descriptions may refer to different aspects of the appearance, but the data does not explain the distinction or provide further finish details. Buyers should consult product images or confirm the finish name with the seller if the exact color matters.

The McCarty body shape is paired with a mahogany neck and a rosewood fingerboard. Bird inlays mark the fingerboard. The guitar has 22 frets, and the neck profile is identified as Pattern Vintage with an asymmetrical shape. No neck thickness measurements, fret dimensions, body weight, or finish type are provided, so those details cannot be assessed from the specifications.

Scale length and setup details

The scale-length information contains a discrepancy. One entry states 635 mm, while the detailed specification gives 624 mm and identifies it as a 24.594-inch scale. These are different measurements, and the available data does not say which value applies to the guitar. The 624 mm entry is internally consistent with the stated inch measurement, but that alone does not confirm the correct factory specification. Verify the scale length with PRS or the retailer before purchase if it affects your decision.

The listing identifies the tremolo system as PRS, but the detailed hardware section names a PRS stoptail bridge. Those descriptions do not match clearly: a stoptail is the specific bridge type stated in the detailed list, while the broader tremolo field is ambiguous. The available information does not clarify whether the guitar has any additional tremolo mechanism. Treat the detailed stoptail description as the more precise entry, while confirming the hardware with the seller.

Pickups and controls

The pickup configuration is HH, meaning two humbuckers. The detailed listing names them as PRS McCarty III treble and bass pickups. Two volume controls provide separate level adjustment, while the two tone controls have push-pull functions for coil splitting. A three-way toggle switch selects between the pickup positions.

Coil splitting changes the pickup circuit from its humbucking configuration, but the specifications do not describe the resulting output, tonal balance, or switching behavior in detail. There are no pickup resistance figures, wiring diagrams, or independent listening tests available here. The control layout is clear, but claims about particular sounds would go beyond the supplied evidence.

Hardware, case, and key specifications

  • Model: McCarty 594, item number 648870
  • Body and top: Mahogany body with a flamed maple top
  • Neck and fingerboard: Mahogany neck, rosewood fingerboard, and bird inlays
  • Neck and frets: Asymmetrical Pattern Vintage profile and 22 frets
  • Pickups and controls: Two PRS McCarty III humbuckers, two volume controls, two push-pull tone controls, and a three-way toggle
  • Bridge and tuners: PRS stoptail bridge and PRS vintage-style tuners, with nickel hardware
  • Included accessories: Case included, gig bag not included
  • Origin: Made in the USA

Technical assessment

The listed components establish a straightforward specification: mahogany construction, a flamed maple top, a rosewood fingerboard, two humbuckers, and coil-split controls. A case is included, while no gig bag is listed. The specification also leaves two points that merit confirmation before ordering: the conflicting scale-length figures and the difference between the general tremolo entry and the detailed stoptail description.

For a purchase decision, the most useful next step is to confirm those details with the retailer and ask for the exact finish description. Beyond that, the supplied data supports an overview of the guitar's materials and control layout, but not a verdict on sound, comfort, setup quality, or value relative to other instruments.

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII, front view
8.2/ 10 overall score
$4,999current price at the retailer
Check today's price price and delivery time at the retailer

Shipping and duties

The retailer ships from its warehouse in Germany. Prices are shown in US dollars and do not include import duties. Orders under roughly $800 usually clear US customs without duty; above that, a duty of a few percent may be collected on delivery. 30-day money-back and a 3-year warranty apply.

Scores by area

Where it shines, where it stumbles

What convinced me

  • Mahogany body and neck with a flamed maple top
  • Two PRS McCarty III humbuckers with push-pull coil splitting
  • Includes a case and is made in the USA

What bugged me

  • The supplied specifications list two different scale lengths: 635 mm and 624 mm
  • The color is described as both Charcoal and Black Top

Is it the right one for you?

Good pick if

A good fit for players seeking a USA-made PRS with dual humbuckers and coil-splitting controls. Also suited to buyers who value a flamed maple top, rosewood fingerboard, and included case.

Look elsewhere if

Not a good fit for buyers who need confirmed scale-length or finish details before purchase. Consider another option if you specifically need a gig bag or a tremolo bridge.
RockBluesJazz

Suggested level: Intermediate

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII, $4,999Check today's price →

Specifications

Limited run
None
Model
McCarty 594
Color
Charcoal
Shape
McCarty
Body
Mahogany
Top
Maple
Neck
Mahogany
Fretboard
Rosewood
Frets
22
Scale
635 mm
Pickup system
HH
Tremolo
PRS
Including case
Yes
Incl. gigbag
No

Watch and listen

Watch the video demo on YouTube →

Before you decide

Questions players ask

Does this guitar include a case?

Yes. The supplied specifications say a case is included, and no gig bag is included.

Can the pickups be split?

Yes. Both tone controls have push-pull functions for coil splitting.

What scale length does this model have?

The specifications conflict: one entry lists 635 mm, while the detailed description lists 624 mm. Confirm the scale length with the seller.

What color is this guitar?

The listing gives both Charcoal and Black Top as the color. Ask the seller to confirm the finish of the specific instrument.

What bridge and tuning machines does it have?

The detailed specifications list a PRS stoptail bridge and PRS vintage-style tuning machines.

The last word from the bench

This USA-made McCarty 594 has a substantial feature set, including a flamed maple top, rosewood fingerboard, PRS stoptail bridge, and included case. Its two humbuckers and push-pull coil splitting offer more tonal options than a fixed humbucker setup. However, the listed scale lengths and color descriptions do not agree, so confirm the exact instrument configuration before ordering. No customer reviews were provided, so this assessment is based on the supplied specifications.

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII, $4,999Check today's price →

Hanging next to it

PRS McCarty 594 Black Top MCIII

Today's price and delivery time are shown at the retailer.

See it at the retailer →
Guitar Gear Reviews Played on the bench before it gets a score